Image via

Olay Eye Cream Product Review

As we age, we tend to face a variety of new experiences, some of which you might call problems.

For example: becoming a little less flexible, or able to move around as freely as you used to, or perhaps you are starting to notice that you have a little less energy than you did in your younger years.

However, one aspect of aging that simply everyone seems to experience, is change to their eyes.

Do you have dark circles beneath or around your eyes? Are you starting to notice a few wrinkles beneath them? Or perhaps your eyes are becoming just simply puffy.

Either way, the skin care and advisor company Olay gives you a solution to this problem.

Olay eye cream is supposed to fight all three: dark circles, wrinkles, and puffiness to make your eyes start looking healthy and young again.

But, is this an investment really worth making?

Honesty is Important to Us

Before starting this review, I want to let you know that honesty, integrity, and accuracy are all important parts of the product review process.

All of these things you find written about Olay Eye Cream are facts provided by the company, not speculation.

Your trust is important, and I know that when looking for the perfect product while on a budget is a hard and risky thing to do.

Therefore, all of our ratings, statistics, and opinions have been formed by the thoughts and opinions of other customers who have tried the product before, as well as how well the product compares to others in the marketplace.

We want to make the process of finding and choosing your new anti-aging product as easy and risk-free as possible, and to do that, we do our best to give you the facts that you need to know, both the good, and the bad.

There is no such thing as a perfect product, but there is such a thing as a right one for you.

What is Olay Eye Cream?

Olay Eye Cream is a product produced by Olay, a skin care and skin advisor company.

Their eye cream comes in a small, oval-shaped jar and is exactly what it says it is: a cream.

The cream is meant to be applied under your eyes and massaged into your skin.  The cream also acts as a concealer and adapts quickly to all skin shades to suit any skin tone or color.

However, it also serves many other purposes and is said to provide you with many more health benefits.

The olay eye cream is made of vitamins and peptides, which make it not only a powerful formula that does its job right, but also to give your skin moisture and instant results.

The cream guarantees instant results, reducing and eliminating the sight of fine lines and wrinkles.

It is also made up of Olay’s signature color correcting technology, which is what makes the cream serve in place of concealer and quickly adapt to all skin tones.

How Does Olay Eye Cream Work?

You already know what this eye cream by Olay has to offer you and what it guarantees to give you.

But what makes Olay so confident in their product? How exactly does this eye cream act as a 3 in 1 to eliminate wrinkles, puffiness, and dark circles with just one product?

Olay’s eye cream is made up of the company’s special formula, which includes primarily peptides and vitamins.  Because of this, the cream acts as a color corrector, which leads to brightening your under eyes as well as hydrating the skin.

To reduce puffiness, the cream’s formula smooths the skin and renews its surface as it is massaged into it.

How Do I Use it?

For the Olay eye cream to work at its best, it is advised to use the cream every morning and evening on cleaned skin.

When applying it, gently massage the cream underneath your eyes, in the corners, and on the lid, with a small amount.  For this cream, a little bit goes a long way.  To ensure that the cream has been applied correctly and that it will do its job, continue massaging it into your skin until it has been completely absorbed.

This means that there should be no excess liquid dripping from your eyes or any spots of the cream visible on your face.

Instead, it should look completely smooth.

Additionally, to ensure safety while using this product, always make sure that you never place the cream or that it never comes in contact directly with your eyeball.

If any ever happens to find its way into your eye, always rinse with water immediately for your safety.

Why Choose Olay Eye Cream?

Now that you already know what the Olay eye cream has to offer you, you are probably wondering what makes it so unique and special compared to all of the other eye creams out there.

Unlike most other creams, the Olay eye cream is a multipurpose product.  Regardless of what problem you are facing with your eyes, whether it be dark circles or wrinkles, this one product promises that it will handle it for you.

Whereas most other products serve only one primary purpose, leaving you with lesser options.

For example, the Olay Eye Cream serves 3 purposes, whereas the Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Anti-Aging Eye Cream takes care of only wrinkles, for only a bit lower price.

Additionally, the Olay eye cream promises instant results the moment you fully apply the cream, whereas most other products take anywhere around 5 days to 2 weeks.

It also acts as a concealer, which means that you not only just got an instant eye lift, but also just did your makeup at the same time.


The olay eye cream is listed for a price of about 20 bucks. 

Also, in the product’s description on the website, Olay states that for the price of this product, you get all of the 3 in 1 benefits for 2x cheaper than the average product.

It has also been declared the #1 Prestige Eye Cream.

On Amazon, the same product is available for roughly the same price. 

[amazon_link asins=’B01EHW5JYI|B01EHW5JYI|B01EHW5JYI’ template=’ImageLink’ store=’weareaging_us-20|weareaging_ca-20|weareaging_uk-21′ marketplace=’US|CA|UK’]

[amazon_link asins=’B01EHW5JYI|B01EHW5JYI|B01EHW5JYI’ template=’ButtonLink’ store=’weareaging_us-20|weareaging_ca-20|weareaging_uk-21′ marketplace=’US|CA|UK’]

What Are Others Saying About It?

On Olay’s website, there is a section at the bottom of each product dedicated to customer reviews and ratings.

For the Olay eye cream, the product has received an overall rating of 3.79 stars out of a 5 star maximum.  This total is the average amount of 129 customer reviews.

When customers leave reviews for Olay’s products on their website, they get to rate the product in 3 different categories: value, effectiveness, and product feel.

For most customers, the average value rating is 3.58 out of 5 stars.

The average effectiveness rating is also 3.58 out of 5 stars.

And finally, the average product feel rating is the lowest, at 3.38 out of 5 stars.

One customer left a review of 5 stars, reporting that the product moisturized and brightened their eye area.  They went on to say that the Olay eye cream is the only one they now use after having tried many at the age of 67, and she no longer needs to wear concealer to cover up underneath her eye.  She says that her skin is clear, bright, and has no fine lines, and that she will continue to use it.

However, another customer reported that the cream is “drying and stinging.”  The customer says that they had been using the cream for 2 weeks but then stopped, due to a stinging sensation around their eyes and wherever they applied it.  They also reported to have dried skin after using the product, and overall, feels that it needs more moisture.  The customer left the product with a 1-star rating for each category.

On Amazon, the product has a 3.5-star review as well, roughly the same as the rating on Olay’s website.

Additionally, reviews on Amazon have been left by a total of 275 customers.

The reviews were also roughly similar, as some customers say that they have literally had overnight results, whereas others sum it up to being not what they had expected.

Olay Eye Cream vs. L’Oréal Eye Defense

[amazon_link asins=’B00005333I|B00005333I|B00005333I’ template=’ImageLink’ store=’weareaging_us-20|weareaging_ca-20|weareaging_uk-21′ marketplace=’US|CA|UK’]

[amazon_link asins=’B00005333I|B00005333I|B00005333I’ template=’ButtonLink’ store=’weareaging_us-20|weareaging_ca-20|weareaging_uk-21′ marketplace=’US|CA|UK’]

A competitor of the Olay eye cream is L’Oréal’s eye defense.

“Eye Defense” is a cream, like that of the Olay eye cream, produced by L’Oréal.  Also, like Olay’s eye cream, Eye Defense fights to reduce and eliminate dark circles, puffiness, and fine lines.

The eye defense is also similar to Olay’s in the sense that it is designed for all skin tones, meaning that despite the color, shade, or tone of your skin, the cream (which is gel-like) will quickly adapt to your individual skin type once you massage it in.

The biggest difference when comparing the L’Oréal eye defense with Olay’s eye perfecting cream is the fact that the Eye Defense product does not have the same special, unique, and signature ingredients in it that Olay’s does.

Instead, L’Oréal Eye Defense is made of 23 different substances, whereas Olay’s contains special vitamins and peptides.

Additionally, some of the L’Oréal Eye Defense ingredients are insanely hard to pronounce, making it hard for customers to understand what it is and the possible effects it could have upon using the product.

For example, some ingredients in Eye Defense include pentaerythrityl tetraethyl hexanoate, polyglycerol, and phenoxyethanol.

However, when it comes to customer reviews, L’Oréal has the advantage.

On the official L’Oréal website, “Eye Defense” has received an overall average 4.0 rating out of a maximum 5 stars.

Similar to Olay, customers who use L’Oréal products can leave reviews and ratings in categories, but only 2: quality of the product, and value of the product.

The average “quality of the product” rating is 4.3 out of 5 stars, and the average “value of the product” rating is 4.0 out of 5 stars.

Customers are leaving reviews stating that they use the product daily and as a result have found that their skin is much tighter around their eyes, working almost instantly.  They praise the product for making their skin look healthier and more “awake” throughout the day.

However, other customers weren’t as satisfied.

One customer reported that their skin started to sting immediately after applying the product to their eye, and the skin became red.  The same customer also said that the eye defense cream had not always been this way, but they had changed the product and she no longer recommends it.

The pricing of L’Oréal’s Eye Defense is also much cheaper, almost by half, than the Olay eye perfecting cream.

Olay Eye Perfecting Cream is a bit more expensive than the L’Oréal Eye Defense. 

However, when it comes to your skin, you may find it necessary to spend a little extra cash for a product that you feel is safer, more widely used, and made up of only 2 ingredients that contribute to the company’s signature formula.

In comparison to the L’Oreal Eye Defense product, Olay’s eye perfecting cream seems to be more widely used as well as a bit safer due to the ingredients it contains.  However, when it comes to ratings and reviews, customers seem to have had more satisfaction with using the L’Oreal product than the customers of Olay’s products had.

What We Think About Olay Eye Cream

There is no such thing as a perfect product, therefore everyone will have different experiences with the same thing.  Some will be good, while some will be bad.

However, with the Olay Eye Perfecting Cream, it seems that more customers are enjoying it than they are hating it, and for most customers it has come through with all of its skin repair promises.

Despite its price, I think it is worth it to have a cream that acts as a 3 in 1 decircler, dewrinkler, and depuffer as well as being able to use it as a substitute for concealer makeup, which could be causing some of these aging effects.

Overall, I think that Olay Eye Cream is a worthy product, with a good purpose and a good reputation.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This