The eyes are the windows to the soul—but they are so much more than that. While our eyes often reveal our emotions, they also tend to reveal things we’d rather they not, such as our age and how much sleep we got last night.

Whether you suffer from puffy bags under your eyes, dark circles, or a few too many wrinkles and creases than you’d prefer, there are ways to treat your eye troubles.

One type of product that many people turn to is eye cream. Eye creams can be used to treat a variety of issues, such as those listed above. They work to provide the delicate skin around your eyes with hydration and soothing ingredients that will leave your skin looking fresh and healthy, giving your eyes a youthful glow.

Before you start celebrating the end of your eye care needs, however, you must first find the perfect product that is not only effective but affordable.

Below, we’ll be reviewing Paula’s Choice Eye Cream to see if it has everything it takes to be a winning skin care product, or if you’d be better off passing it by. We’ve worked hard to provide the most accurate and unbiased information in this review so that you can make the best choice possible.

What is Paula’s Choice Eye Cream?

Paula’s Choice Eye Cream, or more specifically, Paula’s Choice RESIST Anti-Aging Eye Cream, is an eye cream that focuses primarily on reducing the signs of age around the eyes.

Through providing moisturizing and hydrating ingredients, it works to firm the undereye skin, thereby decreasing the appearance of wrinkles and puffiness. Skin should be left feeling firm and refreshed, with results after just one use.

Paula’s Choice Eye Cream Specifications

Key Features

In addition to fighting the wrinkles and fine lines associated with aging, this Anti-Aging Eye Cream also works to brighten dull skin by decreasing puffiness and lightening dark undereye circles.

It’s made to work for all skin types, most specifically combating wrinkles and dry skin.

This eye cream achieves its results specifically through hydration. By nourishing the skin, puffiness and shadows naturally fade, and the skin frees itself of dryness. This allows for that sensitive undereye skin to become firmer and suppler, the elasticity of it easing the appearance of wrinkles and other creases.

The cream is applied at night. This allows for the ingredients to seep into your skin all night long without any disturbance from other products worn during the day or any environmental pollutants. Thus, when you go to bed wearing Paula’s Choice RESIST Anti-Aging eye cream, you can be assured that you’ll wake up and actually look awake, those signs of sleeplessness and age haunting you no longer.

Paula’s Choice claims that you’ll start seeing results after just one night.


Paula’s Choice Eye Cream uses a blend of antioxidants and other hydrating ingredients to firm up and moisturize the undereye skin. The antioxidants work to tighten the skin and replenish it, brightening your undereye area and eliminating puffiness.

To achieve hydration, the cream uses shea butter. This leads to overall healthier skin, lightening the severity of wrinkles and other fine lines—this is because while shea butter offers great moisturizing capabilities, it can also be used as a healing agent.

How to Use

To use this product, you need only apply it once a day. Paula’s Choice generally recommends that you apply it in the evening, as the final stage of your nighttime face care routine. This allows the ingredients and nutrients to work their magic overnight without hindrance for refreshingly smooth and healthy skin when you wake up in the morning.

If used in the morning time instead of at night, apply it before any makeup, and directly follow it with a light SPF to seal in the ingredients and protect the face throughout the day.

Paula’s Choice says to apply their eye cream sparingly, taking a small amount of the cream and lightly patting it into the skin.

​​Product Variations

​Paula’s Choice offers two other variations of eyecare treatment that can work in-tandem with their eye cream, offering superior results.

  • Paula’s Choice RESIST Anti-Aging Eye Gel: Like Paula’s Choice Eye Cream, this product is part of the RESIST series. Where the first product is a hydrating cream, however, this product is a gel that focuses more on easing signs of fatigue and provides environmental protection.

It uses a combination of licorice, peptides, and hyaluronic acid to instantly ease puffiness, smooth lines, and brighten skin. Paula’s Choice recommends using this product twice a day as needed.

  • Paula’s Choice CLINICAL 1% Retinol Treatment: While this product isn’t made for the eyes specifically, it can be used alongside Paula’s Choice Eye Cream for healthier overall skin.

It works to moisturize and rejuvenate the skin, providing a clear complexion and the reduction of wrinkles and other fine lines. It also works to even skin tone and ease redness, so this product will help ease that red puffiness you may have hanging around under your eyes.

What Users Think


When it comes to product reviews, Paula’s Choice Eye Cream is a pretty mixed bag. A lot of users like the cream, saying that the formula is very rich and nourishing, providing lots of hydration. They like the way it makes their skin feel, and they see genuine results.

There are plenty of complaints, however, when it comes to this product. The first and most superficial is its packaging. Users complain that not only do they have a difficult time removing the cap each time from the bottle in the first place, but that it is then difficult to squeeze out.

Additionally, the cream’s thick nature makes it easily separate within the tube, so to properly use it many customers find themselves kneading the tube to get it all mixed in properly.

The thickness also leads to difficulty in application. While some don’t think twice about rubbing products into their skin, others who are more conscious of their skin know that it’s best to lightly pat products until dry.

This is the way that the product’s description suggests applying it, yet users state that it’s too thick to actually apply this way. They also complain of the product’s texture being too grainy.

Still more users complain of the eye cream causing redness and, in some cases, even eczema.


​Paula’s Choice Eye Cream is available for $33/.5 oz. This is relatively cheap compared to other high-end eye creams that are typically priced around $60 or more, though there are other more commercial eye creams available for cheaper.

You can find this eye cream both on the Paula’s Choice website and on Amazon.

[amazon fields=”B014W4VI78″ value=”thumb” image_size=”large”]

[amazon fields=”B014W4VI78″ value=”button” ]

​​How it Compares

Now that we’ve taken a close look at Paula’s Choice RESIST Anti-Aging Eye Cream in its own bubble, let’s get a more well-rounded view of the product by comparing it to other products with similar goals in mind. Below, we’ve directly compared this eye cream to BLANK AND BLANK.

But first, here are a few general stats to keep in mind about Paula’s Choice Eye Cream as we conduct our comparison.

Paula’s Choice RESIST Anti-Aging Eye Cream


    $33/.5 oz

    Ease of Use



    [amazon fields=”B0753JZ26L” value=”thumb” image_size=”large”]

    [amazon fields=”B0753JZ26L” value=”button” ]


    $38/.5 oz

    Ease of Use



    [amazon fields=”B0178HVOAM” value=”thumb” image_size=”large”]

    [amazon fields=”B0178HVOAM” value=”button” ]

    Farmacy is a brand that prides itself on only using the best quality natural ingredients. They commit to using sustainable processes, and for this reason they have a large following of customers who appreciate their policies.

    Dew it All’s name is quite apt, as this is an eye cream that quite literally tries to do it all when it comes to eye care. While many eye creams have a specific target purpose in mind, offering other benefits in the background, this product tries to offer it all in one go. It’s meant to treat wrinkles, decrease puffiness, lighten dark circles, firm up skin, and increase elasticity.

    In addition to reducing signs of age, it’s also geared towards fighting against stress and fatigue. It utilizes its custom Echinacea GreenEnvy™ mixture, along with antioxidants, rose hip, and algae, in comparison to Paula’s Choice Eye Cream’s mixture of antioxidants and shea butter.

    So, with all this to offer, does it actually hold up to its promises? The reviews of this product are mostly positive, customers liking the smooth texture of this product and the way it feels on their skin.

    A few say, however, that this product doesn’t actually do that much in terms of moisturization. Others further state that it doesn’t do much to decrease puffiness and dark circles. The verdict then seems to be a bit hazy: some really like it, while others are less of a fan.

    This product is slightly pricier than the Paula’s Choice product, available for $5 more with the same volume of product.

    Kiehl’s Powerful Wrinkle Reducing Eye Cream


    $43/.5 oz

    Ease of Use



    [amazon fields=”B06X9GW75L” value=”thumb” image_size=”large”]

    [amazon fields=”B06X9GW75L” value=”button” ]

    ​Kiehl’s Powerful Wrinkle Reducing Eye Cream is yet another popular eye cream on the market that aims at easing the signs of age. This eye cream is formulated specifically to nourish the undereye area, treating that delicate skin with the care that it needs.

    In addition to smoothing over wrinkles, this eye cream focuses on improving the elasticity and overall texture of the skin around the eyes, creating smoother, firmer, and healthier-looking skin.

    This Kiehl’s eye cream formula utilizes three key ingredients. The first is copper, which helps to build and stabilize collagen, firming up the undereye area. the second is calcium, which helps defend against the decomposition of collagen in the first place. The last is caffeine, a substance that is proven to reduce undereye puffiness.

    That’s right—not only does caffeine make you feel more awake, it can make you look more awake, too!

    Unlike both the Farmacy and the Paula’s Choice eye creams, this Kiehl’s cream doesn’t do much to reduce the appearance of dark circles under the eyes.

    As for the claims that it reduces puffiness, users deny this as well. Instead, this cream truly is what the title says: a wrinkle reducing eye cream. Whether or not its “powerful” is up to debate.

    Some users have had lots of success in decreasing the appearance of their fine lines and wrinkles, while others state the cream hasn’t done much on that end. Regardless, all sides seem to agree that at the very least it’s a pleasant cream that provides moisture and promotes all-around around-eye skin health.

    While this product doesn’t seem to be anything special, it is free of the complaints that the cream can actually turn harmful like the Paula’s Choice Eye Cream has. Its price is a decent bit higher than that of the Paula’s Choice product, coming in at $43 rather than $33.

    Pros and Cons

    Now that we’ve seen how Paula’s Choice RESIST Anti-Aging Eye Cream stacks up against the competition, let’s do a quick recap of this product’s major pros and cons before we make our final remarks.


    • ​The goals of this eye cream are certainly admirable: aiming to reduce wrinkles, puffiness, and dark circles through providing healing moisture. A lot of users like this product for the moisture it provides, specifically when used at night because it’s too heavy to use during the day. It’s also cheaper than the other eye creams we compared it to.


    • ​There are unfortunately a good deal of cons when it comes to this eye cream. It is thick and unwieldy, separating inside the bottle that it’s difficult to get of in the first place.
    • ​Many people have also had negative reaction to the cream, and the texture itself is rather grainy.

    ​​Conclusions About Paula’s Choice Eye Cream

    When it comes down to it, we can’t recommend this product. While there are plenty of people who love this eye cream and state that their skin has improved and like the hydrating formula, there are just too many issues and complaints with this product.

    If you like very thick creams this product may be for you, but otherwise look into an eye cream option besides Paula’s Choice Eye Cream.

    Overall Rating: 2.5 stars

    Target Keyword: Paula’s Choice Eye Cream

    Pin It on Pinterest

    Share This